Man Silver vs Guilty Pour Homme

Published clone registers name this as the alternative to Gucci Guilty Pour Homme, on a single register. Product identity confirmed against the Zara listing. Not wear-tested; availability, price and delivery are not established.

How they compare

If you enjoy the citrus in Guilty Pour Homme, Man Silver is worth sampling. It’s still unclear exactly how they differ on skin.

Scent accords and expected performance: Man Silver compared with Guilty Pour Homme
AlternativeMan SilverAccord or measureOriginalGuilty Pour Homme
Scent profile
Aromatic
Woody
Citrus
Fresh
Floral
Earthy
White Floral
Patchouli
Performance
Not yet assessedProjectionModerate
Not yet assessedLongevityLong-lasting6–9 hrs
Key differences
  • Less aromatic herbsNot present in Man Silver; estimated 4 out of 5 in Guilty Pour Homme.
  • Less freshNot present in Man Silver; estimated 4 out of 5 in Guilty Pour Homme.
Reading this chart

Estimated prominence, from 1 (a background trace) to 5 (defining). Hour ranges vary by wearer. About these scores

Performance notes

Based on community wear reports. Results vary by skin, application and batch.

Guilty Pour Homme

Reviewed

Six-to-eight-hour accounts with moderate diffusion.

Man Silver

Reviewed

Longevity and projection have not been assessed.

Fragrances with similar accords

Explore scents that share accords with Guilty Pour Homme, ordered by scent profile similarity.